From: Simon J Mudd (no email)
Date: Wed Oct 31 2001 - 18:30:25 EST
On Wed, 31 Oct 2001, Greg A. Woods wrote:
> [ On , October 31, 2001 at 19:01:43 (+0100), Simon J Mudd wrote: ]
> > Subject: Re: another interesting spam trick...
> > While this is actually quite nice, the problem you'll probably find is
> > that you will reject a large number of incorrectly configured smtp
> > clients.
> Actually provided that you allow any locally authorised clients which
> may be running really dumb, broken, or otherwise mis-configured
> software, it's not anywhere near so bad as you make it out to be.
I did this for a while when I was working at All Trading and yes it caught
a few badly configured machines, but not _that_ many. Most postmasters
who I pointed out the problem to (with "friendly messages explaining the
problem") all of a sudden reconfigured their machines correctly.
> Most of the rest are caused by people who clearly should not be allowed
> within a thousand miles of any firewall/NAT configuration.
I've been blocked by you before and imagine I would be in the same
situation now, though I could configure the smtp client appropriately now
if necessary. Do you check that one of the ips is valid when looking up a
hostname with multiple ip addresses? (I can't fix the reverse DNS as the
addresses are not owned by me.)
> I get a lot of invalid HELO/EHLO names on my own personal servers, but
> 99.99% are confirmed spam sources (including hotmail! ;-). Only very
> ocasionally does someone I know accidentally screw up their
> configuration and get caught by this check.
I'll have to insist a bit more and try and get on your white list :-)
> > I would guess Wietse never implemented this for that reason,
> > as I think that the check is available on other MTAs. (smail?)
> Yes, and Exim.
> HELO/EHLO parameter validation is a very powerful anti-spam feature and
> it really doesn't cause problems for a "lot" of SMTP clients in the real
> Like mengwong says in another reply: "That's what they said about
> closed relays."
Yes I think it would be useful too, even if it would affect me.
-- Simon J Mudd, Madrid SPAIN. email: Tel: +34-91-408 4878, Mobile: +34-605-085 219 - To unsubscribe, send mail to with content (not subject): unsubscribe postfix-users