From: Alexander Harrowell (no email)
Date: Sun Jan 21 2007 - 14:41:12 EST
Sprunk:
> > It's a nice idea to collect popularity data at the ISP level, because
> > the decision on what to load into the local torrent servers could be
> > automated.
>
> Note that collecting popularity data could be done at the edges without
> forcing all tracker requests through a transparent proxy.
Yes. This is my point. It's a good thing to do, but centralising it is an
ungood thing to do, because...
> Once torrent X reaches a certain trigger level of popularity, the
> > local
> > server grabs it and begins serving, and the local-pref function on the
> > clients finds it. Meanwhile, we drink coffee. However, it's a
> > potential
> > DOS magnet - after all, P2P is really a botnet with a badge.
>
> I don't see how. If you detect that N customers are downloading a
> torrent, then having the ISP's peer download that torrent and serve it
> to the customers means you consume 1/N upstream bandwidth. That's an
> anti-DOS :)
All true. My point is that forcing all tracker requests through a proxy
makes that machine an obvious DDOS target. It's got to have an open
interface to all hosts on your network on one side, and to $world on the
other, and if it goes down, then everyone on your network loses service. And
you're expecting traffic distributed over a large number of IP addresses
because it's a P2P application, so distinguishing normal traffic from a
botnet attack will be hard.
> And the point of a topology-aware P2P client is that it seeks the
> > nearest host, so if you constrain it to the ISP local server only,
> > you're
> > losing part of the point of P2P for no great saving in
> > peering/transit.
>
> That's why I don't like the idea of transparent proxies for P2P; you can
> get 90% of the effect with 10% of the evilness by setting up sane
> rate-limits.
OK.
> As long as they don't interfere with the user's right to choose
> > someone
> > else's content, fine.
>
> If you're getting it from an STB, well, there may not be a way for users
> to add 3rd party torrents; how many users will be able to figure out how
> to add the torrent URLs (or know where to find said URLs) even if there
> is an option? Remember, we're talking about Joe Sixpack here, not
> techies.
>
> You would, however, be able to pick whatever STB you wanted (unless ISPs
> deliberately blocked competitors' services).
Please. Joe has a right to know these things. How long before Joe finds out
anyway?
|
|
|